Below is an annotated list of children's literature for the elementary classroom. The books are organized by the Six Elements of Social Justice Curriculum Design (Picower, 2007). It is based on work by pre-service teachers at Montclair State University. They have read and reviewed these books and provided insights into how they can be used in K-5 settings.
Tuesday, April 2, 2013
SIT-IN How Four Friends Stood Up By Sitting Down
Author: Andrea Davis Pinkney
Illustrator: Brian Pinkney
Grade Level: 2nd Grade- Up
Buy It Here!
References
Summary: SIT-IN How Four Friends Stood Up By Sitting Down, by Andrea Davis Pinkney, involves 4 young African-American men who took a stand for the injustice of segregation. Following Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s ideas about non-violent protest, these men sat down at a "white's only" counter at a restaurant and ordered a simple meal. In the beginning, the men were ignored and the employees acted as if they weren't even there. After coming back day after day and continuously being ignored, other individuals decided to "sit down"with them, including white men. By taking the criticism from others, having food thrown at them, and not being served, these men and other individuals were standing up for the equality of all individuals. Because of situations like this, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was created in order to eliminate future problems containing segregation.
Element 4: This book refers to the social justice element of social movements and social change for numerous reasons. These 4 men came together and addressed/protested issues in regards to the injustice of segregation. They continued to got to the restaurant on a daily basis, and with the help of other individuals who got involved, they made a change in the world. Because of them taking a stand, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was created, and it shows the readers how important it is to stand up for what you believe in order to make a positive change.
Activity: After reading this book with my classroom and having a mini class discussion about their thoughts and opinions, I would have each student take out a journal. In that journal, I would have them pick a specific part in the book that they felt strongly about, and describe why they liked it the most. In addition, I would have them write how/why it was an important aspect of the book as as whole. After having the kids do this individually, I would bring them together as a class to share what they have written in their journal. I would jot down these ideas on the board, and have the class pick their 4 or 5 favorite scenes. Lastly, in groups, I would assign those scenes and have the children draw their own picture and write down what was happening. We could hang them in the room as a reminder of the book, and to show kids how important social movements and social change are in the world.
The Bobbin Girl
Author &
Illustrator: Emily Arnold McCully
Grade Level: 3 to
5
Summary
In The Bobbin Girl,
Emily Arnold McCully tells of the story of life in the mills of Lowell, Massachusetts
during the 1830s. Rebecca
Putney is a ten-year-old bobbin girl working in the mills to earn money for her
family. While working at the mills
in Lowell, Massachusetts, Rebecca and her friends endure fourteen-hour days,
poor factory conditions, and low wages.
When information spreads that the girls’ wages will be reduced even
lower, Rebecca’s friend Judith calls for the bobbin girls to rise up and take
action. Judith suggests the girls
go on strike until Mr. Capsaw, the factory supervisor, improves their wages and
working conditions. Rebecca is
faced with the decision to take part in the protest or continue to work in the
mill to support her family. When
empowered by her mother to do the right thing, Rebecca takes a stand with
hundreds of other factory workers in the first worker’s strike in Lowell. Although management did not listen to
the demands of the workers, the girls continue to work in the mills and fought
for better conditions.
McCully’s main character, Rebecca Putney, is loosely based
on Harriet Hanson Robinson, a mill girl who was active in abolishing slavery
and worked for women’s rights.
McCully’s story depicts the first strike in Lowell. Though it was unsuccessful, Robinson
continued to fight for better treatment, pay, and working conditions.
Relationship to
Element 4: Social Movements and Social Change
Element 4 discusses the importance of recognizing social
injustices and how ordinary people have united and worked together to generate
change. In The Bobbin Girl,
ten-year-old Rebecca Putney bans together with other working mills girls to
stand up and take action against the poor working conditions, mistreatment, and
the low wages they are receiving.
By continuing to ban together, the mills girls were able to create
change over the course of decades.
This story shows that an ordinary person, even a ten-year-old girl, can
help create change. Although it
can be used at any grade level, The
Bobbin Girl is a good fit for grades 3 to 5 because the main character is
the same age as the students in those grades. This helps make the story relatable to young children and
inspire them to create change.
Activity
From reading The
Bobbin Girl, I would want my students to understand what social injustices
populations have faced and what they could do to overcome them. I would use this story as a read
aloud. While reading the story to
the class, I would create a t-chart that charts the social injustices the mill
girls faced and the action they took to create change. As we read through the story, we will
add more information to the chart.
Once we have completed the story, the chart, and discussed the Lowell
strike, I would have the children place themselves in the factory alongside
Rebecca. Now that they understand
the social injustices and how ordinary people can ban together, I want them to
use the power of the press to create a newspaper article about the Lowell strike. During the 1840s, the mill girls
contributed to a monthly periodical called The
Lowell Offering. This
publication included news articles, poems, and stories produced by the mill
girls.
The children will create the headlining story for The Lowell Offering. To produce their
newspaper article, the children will come up with a catchy heading and article
that incorporates the information we recorded on our t-chart. Since most headlining newspaper
articles have pictures, I would print out a variety of historical photographs
of factory conditions and worker’s strikes from Lowell, Massachusetts. The children will pick a photograph,
and recreate it using watercolor painting, similar to how Emily Arnold McCully
illustrated The Bobbin Girl.
That's Not Fair! Emma Tenayuca's Struggle for Justice/ No Es Justo! La Lucha de Emma Tenayuca por la Justicia
Title: That's Not Fair! Emma Tenayuca's Struggle for Justice/ No Es Justo! La Lucha de Emma Tenayuca por la Justicia
Authors: Carmen Tafolla and Sharyll Teneyuca
Illistrator: Terry Ybanez
Grade: K - 2
Buy it Here!! Even has a Kindle version!!
Background information about the authors, illustrator, and main character
Teacher Resource (Video)
Summary:
This book is a true story of how a little Mexican-American girl from San Antonio in the 1920's -1930's who helped to raise awareness of the poverty and starvation hitting her people. Emma Tenayuca leads the first major Mexican-American movement to eliminate their struggles because of long hours and cheap labor her people do. Emma first noticed injustices as she walked to school one day. she saw a mother with a thin shawl and a crying baby. She also saw three little boys who were sharing food, she thought this might be the only food they have all day to eat. After school she returned home and saw her neighbor maria. Maria informed Emma that she didn't know how to read because she was never at school very long. This was because of her family moving to plant and harvest different crops. Emma didn't think any of these disadvantages to be fair because she had so much and they had so little. Emma talked to her grandfather about it and how unfair it really was. He took her around town looking at what disadvantages really are there for fellow Mexican-Americans. He said to Emma, "Sometimes things are not fair. But, still, each one of us can usually do something about it, even if its just a little thing." This truly changed Emma's life. When she was a teenager she was present at different protests and at 21 she organized a walk out at a pecan factory who was paying incredibly low wages to their Mexican-American workers. 12,000 people for nearly two months did not work. This caused the Pecan factory owners to raise the wages. Emma had given the poor a voice and had improved their lives a little bit more.
Element 4: Social Movement and Social Change
Emma Tenayuca helped in the first Mexican-American movement in the United states. This story is able to show children that no matter your age you can do anything for anyone. Emma as a child helped her local community. She gave some food, clothes, and reading lessons to those in the community. As a teenager she learned the art of protesting and negotiation to achieve the goal at hand. Emma at 21 arranged a walk out when the business owners would not hear her pleas to arrange higher wages. Students reading this book or basing a lesson on this book will help to have students feeling empowered to know someone who was their age went out and did something about the wrongs she saw in society.
Activity:
The students, like Emma, can find different disadvantages that have happened in their own cultural pasts and how they overcame them. They can also look at their own communities at things they would like to change and why. This could be done like Emma and her grandfather. They looked at different houses in their communities and jobs in their communities. If it is allowed the teacher could even go with the students to look. Depending on the community some disadvantages may be less apparent but even something simplistic to make the students lives better would be a win win situation.
Authors: Carmen Tafolla and Sharyll Teneyuca
Illistrator: Terry Ybanez
Grade: K - 2
Buy it Here!! Even has a Kindle version!!
Background information about the authors, illustrator, and main character
Teacher Resource (Video)
Summary:
This book is a true story of how a little Mexican-American girl from San Antonio in the 1920's -1930's who helped to raise awareness of the poverty and starvation hitting her people. Emma Tenayuca leads the first major Mexican-American movement to eliminate their struggles because of long hours and cheap labor her people do. Emma first noticed injustices as she walked to school one day. she saw a mother with a thin shawl and a crying baby. She also saw three little boys who were sharing food, she thought this might be the only food they have all day to eat. After school she returned home and saw her neighbor maria. Maria informed Emma that she didn't know how to read because she was never at school very long. This was because of her family moving to plant and harvest different crops. Emma didn't think any of these disadvantages to be fair because she had so much and they had so little. Emma talked to her grandfather about it and how unfair it really was. He took her around town looking at what disadvantages really are there for fellow Mexican-Americans. He said to Emma, "Sometimes things are not fair. But, still, each one of us can usually do something about it, even if its just a little thing." This truly changed Emma's life. When she was a teenager she was present at different protests and at 21 she organized a walk out at a pecan factory who was paying incredibly low wages to their Mexican-American workers. 12,000 people for nearly two months did not work. This caused the Pecan factory owners to raise the wages. Emma had given the poor a voice and had improved their lives a little bit more.
Element 4: Social Movement and Social Change
Emma Tenayuca helped in the first Mexican-American movement in the United states. This story is able to show children that no matter your age you can do anything for anyone. Emma as a child helped her local community. She gave some food, clothes, and reading lessons to those in the community. As a teenager she learned the art of protesting and negotiation to achieve the goal at hand. Emma at 21 arranged a walk out when the business owners would not hear her pleas to arrange higher wages. Students reading this book or basing a lesson on this book will help to have students feeling empowered to know someone who was their age went out and did something about the wrongs she saw in society.
Activity:
The students, like Emma, can find different disadvantages that have happened in their own cultural pasts and how they overcame them. They can also look at their own communities at things they would like to change and why. This could be done like Emma and her grandfather. They looked at different houses in their communities and jobs in their communities. If it is allowed the teacher could even go with the students to look. Depending on the community some disadvantages may be less apparent but even something simplistic to make the students lives better would be a win win situation.
I Could Do That!: Esther Morris Gets Women the Vote
Illustrator:
Nancy Carpenter
Grade:
2-5
Summary:
Esther
Morris believes she can do anything and proves she can. At six Esther is told she is too young
to make tea. Her reply? “I could
do that!” and she does. At
nineteen she is told she is much too young to open up her own business. What is Esther’s reply? “I don’t see
why” and she opened a hat shop.
Esther then marries and has a son.
When her husband passes away Esther moves to Illinois and tries her
hardest to claim her late husband’s land but is denied her inheritance because
she is a woman. In 1869 Esther
moves to Wyoming. In Wyoming,
Esther sees a proclamation stating “ALL MALE CITIZENS 21 AND OLDER ARE CALLED
TO VOTE IN THE FIRST TERRITORIAL ELECTIONS.” What Is Esther’s reply? “Is’s time I did that.” From that point forward Esther makes
getting women the right to vote her goal.
She holds meetings and persuades the candidates for territorial
legislate to agree to introduce a bill for women’s rights. After letters and visits the bill is
finally signed on December 10, 1869, and women in Wyoming get the right to vote
thanks to Esther. When the
county’s justice of the peace resigns, refusing to administer justice to a place
that allows women to vote, Esther takes his position and becomes the first
women to hold office in the United States. Esther Morris can do anything!
Element
Four:
Element
Four, social movements and social change focuses on teaching students about the
everyday and iconic people who worked together to stand up for what they
believed in to create change. “I
Could Do That!: Esther Morris Gets Women the Vote,” is a wonderful
representation of element four.
The story of Esther Morris teaches children that they can do the
unexpected. It also teaches them
that if they fight for what they believe in they can make a difference and
create change.
Many of Esther’s accomplishments were not typical of a woman in the
1800s because of the societal restrictions women had placed upon them. However, Esther challenges the norms of
the time and opens her own business, moves out to Illinois as a single mother,
gets women the right to vote in Wyoming, and becomes the first women in the
United States to hold public office.
Although Esther is a historical figure she is not famous like Elizabeth
Cady Stanton or Susan B. Anthony and teaches children that anyone can create
change by taking action.
Activity:
To
incorporate “Could Do That!: Esther Morris Gets Women the Vote” into the
classroom, children can have a class discussion about stereotypes. Children can be asked questions like,
“What is a stereotype?” “What did people during Esther’s time believe women
could not do?” “Is there anything
women cannot do today?” After the discussion and breaking down any stereotypes
children may have, the teacher can present students with the stereotype that
children cannot make a difference.
Ask them how that makes them feel then share with them a few examples of
how children created big change.
Use examples like the Fair Trade Chocolate Project.
After discussing how
these children have created change ask how Esther created change. Using what they have learned from
Esther’s story and the information about the examples of children who have
created organizations for change, ask the children to write about something
they would like to change, at school, home, in the United States, or the
world. Have them include in their
writing what they would like to change, why they would like to change it, and
how they can take action to create a difference.
The Other Side
Title: The Other Side
Author: Jacqueline Woodson
Illustrator: E.B. Lewis
Age level: 7-10 years / 3-5th grade
Summary:
The main
character of the story, who also takes on the roll of the narrator, is a young African American girl
named Clover. In the town where she
lives there is a large fence that divides the community in half separating the
blacks from the whites. Everyday when Clover goes outside to play she sees a
young white girl on the other side of the fence. No matter what kind of day it
is, the girl is always playing outside, even on rainy days. Clover is intrigued
by this and leaves her friends jumping rope to go sit on top of the fence with
the white girl named Annie. The two girls sit on top of the fence enjoying one
another’s company day after day. Finally, Annie decides to climb over the fence
to join the girls in a jump rope game and all the girls come to realize how
similar they are to one another regardless of skin color, they all simply love
to play outside.
Element 4:
Social Movements and Social Change
Element four
discusses "people standing together to address the issues of social injustice
that were learned from element three". This book allows students to see that
change can be created with the simplest of actions. The book sheds light upon a
more symbolic notion that true change involves climbing over the fence, being
bold, and making sacrifices, just as Annie did when she decided to join Clover
and her friends jumping rope. As stated in the element four description,
“Social change is possible only if you engage and put forth your own effort. It
is not something than can be taken care of by others”. The Other Side truly captures this statement and allows student to
understand that coming together is a critical strategy to bettering society.
Classroom usage:
The
Other Side can
be used as a great tool to introduce and integrate segregation into a lesson
plan. Students can learn about how intense of a roll skin color played during
the Black Era, and can see a real example of how black and white communities
were separated. As a teacher, I would ask my fifth grade students to think
critically about the symbolic meaning behind climbing over fences and perhaps
ask them to identify the obstacle that Annie and Clover overcame in the story. The students could
then think about their own fences that they have climbed over in the past and
perhaps fences they plan to climb over in the near future. To do this, students
can create a list of accomplished and soon-to-be accomplished goals in a the form of a T-chart. The students could then proceed to discuss their goals and experiences with their peers.
Monday, April 1, 2013
You Forgot Your Skirt, Amelia Bloomer!
Author: Shana Corey
Illustrator: Chesley McLaren
Grade Level:K-4
Buy it here!
Additional Resources
Summary:
Amelia Bloomer is sick and tired of always being uncomfortable! Because this book takes place in the mid-nineteenth century, in order to be considered a 'proper woman' women were forced to wear extremely uncomfortable and heavy clothing such as wide hooped skirts, and corsets. Amelia not only wishes to change the fashion choices of women, but also the rights that women are able to receive. During this time women who worked were frowned upon, and women were also not allowed to vote. Amelia decides its time for a change and becomes actively involved in gaining more rights for women. Amelia starts her own newspaper in an attempt to change the voting laws. She also begins wearing a new style rather than her normal skirt called 'bloomers' or baggy pants. By the end of the story, Amelia's new fashion is trending throughout all of the women in the neighborhood!
Element 4: Social Movements and Social Change
This topic relates to Element 4 because it shows that Amelia feels so passionately about the mistreatment of women and because of this, she decides to do something about it. She does not simply accept things the way that they are, she realizes that even though she is just one person, she has the power to change the views and actions of people if she tries hard enough and believes in herself and her cause. By the end of the story, Amelia successfully makes a change in the way that women dress, and improves her community for the better considering the women do not constantly have to worry about fainting, or lugging around 40 pounds of clothes each day. Reading this book should empower students and show them that it is possible for them to make a change. After reading this book students will realize they can do absolutely anything they set their mind to.
Activity:
A fun extension activity one could do with their students after reading, "You Forgot Your Skirt, Amelia Bloomer!" is on a nice day, bring students outside. Bring a variety of large clothing such as sweatshirts, shirts, etc... as well as a backpack full of heavy items. Have students have a relay race wearing these items, running to the cone, and then handing off the items to their teammates. After students have this relay race, have a class discussion on how difficult it was to run with these items, and explain that the way they felt is similar to the way women felt in the mid-nineteenth century when they were forced to wear these uncomfortable outfits. This will give students insight on what women had to deal with back then, and why it was important that changes were implemented.
Esperanza Rising
Author: Pam Muñoz Ryan
Grade Level: 4th-5th
Buy it here!
Resources
Summary: Esperanza had a carefree early childhood, growing up the only child of prosperous Mexican ranchers. However, after the death of her father, she and her mother must move from their native land of Mexico to California, in order to escape a family member's tyranny. Esperanza's struggle to adjust to her difficult new life as a migrant worker is compounded by her mother's illness. Esperanza must decide if she will join her peer Marta and become involved in a strike for better working conditions.
This novel effectively shows the complexity of labor strikes; students will better understand the reasons for choosing or not choosing to take this type of social action.
Element 4: The fourth element of social justice addresses the idea that students can make social change. Esperanza and her peer Marta are young women who have to decide whether or not to participate in an important social movement (a strike among migrant workers). Marta chooses to join, while Esperanza does not. Marta provides an example of a young person who is determined to make a social change. Through her character, students will see that it is possible for a young person to actively participate in and help organize a social movement.
Activity: After reading the chapter entitled "Los Aguacates," (pg 179-198) discuss whether or not Esperanza will join the strike. Organize the class into two groups: One is for Esperanza joining the strike, the other against it. Have the students discuss the pros and cons of striking. The group that is for striking should write an ending for the story, pretending Esperanza does decide to strike. The group that is opposed to Esperanza striking should write an ending for the story, pretending Esperanza does not decide to strike.
The book provides a segue into topics like immigration, migrant workers' rights, labor strikes, and working conditions. Students can research migrant worker life, discuss changes that can be made to improve working conditions, and contact government officials about proposed changes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




